The Maker Mom

Helping parents raise STEM-loving, Maker-friendly kids

  • Home
  • About
  • Work With Us
  • When Geeks Grow Up
  • Gifted Kids
  • Videos
  • #STEMchat
  • STEM
  • STEM Girls
  • Chicago
  • Maker Projects
  • Gifted Ed
  • Product Reviews

Gifted Kids and Skinny Dipping in the School Pool

March 27, 2014 By Kim
Tagged With: education funding, gifted education, gifted kids, parenting gifted kids, public school

Why Today's Gifted Ed is Like Yesterday's Swimming Naked in the Pool from TheMakerMom.com
Did you see this article on gifted education in a recent issue of the Boston Globe? Though oddly titled, it did a good job of making a case for why the needs of gifted students should be a national priority. Here are a couple of the money quotes:

Even among Study of Mathematically Precocious Youth participants, the Vanderbilt researchers have previously found that those who weren’t challenged in school were less likely to live up to the potential indicated by their test scores. 

and

But if the study is right that exceptional youthful ability really does correlate directly with exceptional adult achievement, then these talented young kids aren’t just a challenge for schools and parents: they’re also demonstrably important to America’s future. And it means that if, in education, we focus on steering all extra money and attention toward kids who are struggling academically, or even just to the average student, we risk shortchanging the country in a different way.

We don’t see this kind of article in the mainstream press nearly often enough. At any rate, the article got me thinking about a post that I originally published on the Chicago Moms Blog in November of 2009. I’m reposting as part of my Gifted Education Throwback Thursday series.

Gifted Kids and Skinny Dipping in the School Pool

Back in the 1950s when my dad was a student in a Chicago Public School, the naked truth was that the boys went swimming in the buff during PE class. As Mark Brown described in a recent column in the Chicago Sun-Times, “This was an organized school activity where gym teachers would order their students to take off their clothes and get in the pool for swimming instruction.”
I remember my father telling my brother and I such things every time we drove past Lane Tech on the North Side. As a modest child, skinny dipping sounded odd enough, but swimming naked alongside your classmates?Unthinkable.

Now that I’m a wizened adult the whole idea sounds completely whacked. Eventually others must have agreed; the practice was abolished. According to Brown it faded away during the mid-1970s, but it’s still hard for me to fathom how it remained in place for so long. I realize that moms back then weren’t searching the Internet for convicted pedophiles in their neighborhood, background checks were unheard of, and they likely never gave their children the good touch/bad touch talk, but still something about a pool–a school pool, no less– full of naked teenage boys just seems weird. I’d think it would take less than two decades for someone to speak up.
Then again, I attended school in an era when anyone and everyone had free and open access to our buildings and the students within. My gosh, we’d never even heard the term lockdown, let alone practice one. And (hold onto your chair) my brother and I slept over at a teacher’s house.
I suppose that at some point we’ll look back at today’s gifted education standards and shake our heads in amazement. A national education policy that ignored our most competent and highest performing students? What were we thinking? Now that I’m reflecting on it, that may cause even more embarrassment than boys without bathing suits.

Comments

  1. Gail Post, Ph.D. says

    March 28, 2014 at 12:55 pm

    Great analogy about how absurd the approach to gifted ed SHOULD seem to everyone. Unfortunately, as we know, so many schools ignore and these children. Thanks for all of your work.

    Gail Post, Ph.D./ http://www.giftedchallenges.com

STEMchat 3 gears

About Kim

Kim headshot Summer 2012 I’m a Chicago-area mom of teen boys who is passionate about sharing ideas and resources to raise kids who love Science, Technology, Engineering and Math (STEM). I’m a blogger, vlogger, baker and maker, as well as the founder of #STEMchat. I also write about parenting gifted kids, girls in STEM and the Maker Movement. [Read More...]
" "

"

"

Read Me Here:

blogger

Ads and Affiliates

Archives

BLOG TOPICS

#STEMchat (42) apps (5) Big Hero 6 (5) book review (14) books (37) Chicago (56) coding (30) coding for kids (5) computer programming (17) computers (6) contests for kids (14) DIY (46) engineering (13) family fun (101) geek camp (22) gifted education (19) gifted kids (6) giveaway (5) guest post (12) how to (20) kickstarter (6) kit (10) maker projects (31) makerspace (18) math (16) parenting gifted kids (9) product review (55) projects (65) recipe (5) robotics (11) robots (29) science (14) special STEM day or week (40) sponsored (16) STEAM (22) STEM (111) STEM at work (6) STEM camp (11) STEM competitions (8) STEM gifts (6) STEM Girl Friday (38) STEM Girls (92) technology (33) video (13) Women in STEM (6)

Copyright © 2021 THE MAKER MOM, SITE DESIGNED BY RK RESPONSIVE DESIGN